Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription Access
Open Access Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Restricted Access Subscription Access

Ambiguous Certainty: Descriptions of "Non-Complete Architecture" in Kafka's Writings


Affiliations
1 Holon Institute of Technology, Israel
     

   Subscribe/Renew Journal


"Non-Complete Architecture" refers to architecture that contradicts the ideal aspiration towards the complete and the finished, towards stability and unity. The "Non-Complete" condition preserves its independence without offering a beginning or an end; it offers only constant instability, without an ambition to attain conclusion and completion. The paper identifies descriptions of architecture within the literary writings of Czech writer Franz Kafka. Kafka's writing explores hesitation, ambiguity, wavering, and uncertainty, all issues that are relevant to the concept of the "Non-Complete." Kafka uses unresolved, uninviting, confusing, and sometimes impossible architectural conditions. The research scrutinizes his writings, identifying examples of architectural descriptions. It explains and defines them according to their relevance to "Non-Complete Architecture." It explores the ways these examples enhance and elaborate the concept of "Non-Complete" in architecture. The objective of "Non-Complete Architecture" varies and alludes, yet it has a reconciliation force that attempts to balance between the incompleteness of reality and the conflicting objectives of architecture. As such, the research attempts to explore the possible contributions of architectural descriptions within literature to architecture and to design education. Finally, it explores the possible benefit of this cross-disciplinary method of research to architecture and architectural theory.

Keywords

Architecture, Literature, Design Education, Non-Complete Architecture.
Subscription Login to verify subscription
User
Notifications
Font Size

  • Bar-Eli, Amos. 2011. On the Non-Complete in Visionary Architecture. Berlin: Lambert Academic Publishing.
  • Evans, Robin. 1995. The projective cast: Architecture and its Three Geometries. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
  • Hisarligil, Beyhan Bolak. 2012. "Franz Kafka in the Design Studio: A Hermeneutic-Phenomenological Approach to Architectural Design Education." International Journal of Art & Design Education 31 (3): 256-264.
  • Kafka, Franz. 1995. The Metamorphosis, In the Penal Colony, and Other Stories. New-York: Schocken Books.
  • Kafka, Franz. Trans. Herman, Mark. 1998. The Castle. New-York: Schocken Books. e-book edition. http://www.scribd.com/doc/134656995/The-Castle-by-Franz-Kafka.
  • Kafka, Franz. 1975. Parables and Paradoxes. New-York: Schocken Books.
  • Karl, Frederick R. 1977. "Space, Time, and Enclosure in The Trial and The Castle." Journal of Modern Literature 6: 389-397.
  • Kwinter, Sanford. 2001. Architectures of Time: toward a Theory of the Event in Modernist Culture. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
  • Levy, Itamar. 2012. Home and Road: Reflections on the psychoanalytic Imagination. Tel-Aviv: Resling Publishing. [In Hebrew].
  • Mairowitz, David Z., and Crumb, Robert. 2006. Introducing Kafka. Minneapolis: Totem Books. Pessoa, Fernando. 2006. The Book of Disquiet. Tel-Aviv: Babel. [In Hebrew].
  • Restrepo, John and Christiaans, Henri. 2004. "Problem Structuring and Information Access in Design." Journal of Design Research, 4: 1551-69.
  • Tschumi, Bernard.1996. Architecture and Disjunction. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
  • Sandbank, Shimon. 1974. The Way of Wavering - Forms of Uncertainty in Kafka. Tel-Aviv: Ha'kibutz Ha'meuchad Publishing. [In Hebrew].
  • Steinsaltz, David. 1992. "Kafka's Geometry." Seminar: A Journal of Germanic Studies 28: 334-350
  • Wittkower, Rudolf. 1998 (1949). Architectural Principles in the Age of Humanism. 4th ed. London: Academy Editions.

Abstract Views: 159

PDF Views: 0




  • Ambiguous Certainty: Descriptions of "Non-Complete Architecture" in Kafka's Writings

Abstract Views: 159  |  PDF Views: 0

Authors

Amos Bar-Eli
Holon Institute of Technology, Israel

Abstract


"Non-Complete Architecture" refers to architecture that contradicts the ideal aspiration towards the complete and the finished, towards stability and unity. The "Non-Complete" condition preserves its independence without offering a beginning or an end; it offers only constant instability, without an ambition to attain conclusion and completion. The paper identifies descriptions of architecture within the literary writings of Czech writer Franz Kafka. Kafka's writing explores hesitation, ambiguity, wavering, and uncertainty, all issues that are relevant to the concept of the "Non-Complete." Kafka uses unresolved, uninviting, confusing, and sometimes impossible architectural conditions. The research scrutinizes his writings, identifying examples of architectural descriptions. It explains and defines them according to their relevance to "Non-Complete Architecture." It explores the ways these examples enhance and elaborate the concept of "Non-Complete" in architecture. The objective of "Non-Complete Architecture" varies and alludes, yet it has a reconciliation force that attempts to balance between the incompleteness of reality and the conflicting objectives of architecture. As such, the research attempts to explore the possible contributions of architectural descriptions within literature to architecture and to design education. Finally, it explores the possible benefit of this cross-disciplinary method of research to architecture and architectural theory.

Keywords


Architecture, Literature, Design Education, Non-Complete Architecture.

References