Journal of Physics & Astronomy

Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription Access

An Alternative Explanation of the ‘Spokes’ Observed in Saturn’s Rings


Affiliations
1 Independent Researcher, Secondary Teacher + HoD Science, Australia., Australia
 

Observed first by amateur astronomer Stephen J. O’Meara in the 1970s and then subsequently observed by the Voyager Spacecraft flybys in the early 1980s (FIG. 1)[1], it was realized that the ‘spokes’ flare out like spokes on a bicycle wheel. The observed behavior of the ‘spokes’ indicates that they are not governed by gravitational interactions with the planet, moons, or ring material. In 2005 the Cassini probe confirmed that the ‘spokes’ are likely under the influence of the gas giant’s global magnetic field[2]. Here we show the ‘spokes’ that appear in Saturn’s rings consist of grains of silicates coated in pyrolytic carbon through the process of Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD).

Pyrolytic carbon is a highly diamagnetic substance that can levitate above a sufficiently strong magnetic field. The ‘spokes’ also consist of ice particles that are diamagnetic as well. The photoelectric effect can be used to explain why the silicates coated in pyrolytic carbon return to the main ring structure when exposed to sunlight of a specific frequency. The pyrolytic carbon grains become paramagnetic when some of the unhybridised 2pz orbitals lose their unpaired delocalized electrons, thus collapsing the π bond molecular orbital structure. The pyrolytic carbon grains are now attracted towards the magnetic field emanating above and below the main ring structure. It is suggested that the ‘spokes’ in Saturn’s B ring are always present and that no plasma triggering event is required to increase plasma density. The ‘spokes’, however, are only visible when a favorable viewing angle is allowed, and their visibility is also dependent on the angle of the sunlight hitting Saturn’s rings.


Keywords

Diamagnetic, Photoelectric Effect
User
Notifications
Font Size

  • Bryan J. Stephen J. O'Meara and Ring Spokes Before Voyager 1. J. Astron. Hist. Herit. 2007;10:148-50.

  • Mitchell CJ, Horányi M, Havnes O, et al. Saturn's spokes: Lost and found. Science. 2006;311(5767):1587-9.

  • Hartquist TW, Havnes O, Morfill GE. The effects of charged dust on Saturn's rings. Astron. Geophys. 2003;44(5):5-26.

  • Cassini.Ghostly spokes in rings, NASA.2010

  • Jones GH, Krupp N, Kr¨uger H, et al. Formation of saturn’s ring spokes by lightning-induced electron beams. Geophysical research letters. 2006;33(21).

  • Goertz CK. Formation of Saturn's spokes. Adv. Space Res. 1984;4(9):137-41.

  • Farmer AJ and Goldreich P. Spokes in saturn’s rings. In Am. Astron. Soc. Meet. Abstr, 2004;205:43–07.

  • Levitating pyrolytic carbon

  • Henning T, Semenov D. Chemistry in protoplanetary disks. Chemical Reviews. 2013;113(12):9016-42.

  • Protoplanetary disk formation

  • Chown M. Cassini: Lord of the rings. New Scientist. 2010;208(2789):40-1.

  • Boss AP. Temperatures in protoplanetary disks. Annu. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci. 1998;26(1):53-80.

  • Fukuhara M. Possible nuclear fusion of deuteron in the cores of Earth, Jupiter, Saturn, and brown dwarfs. AIP Advances. 2020;10(3):035126.

  • Spilker L. Cassini-Huygens’ exploration of the Saturn system: 13 years of discovery. Science. 2019;364(6445):1046-51.

  • Composition of ring rain, National Geographic

  • Waite Jr JH, Perryman RS, Perry ME, et al. Chemical interactions between Saturn’s atmosphere and its rings. Science. 2018;362(6410):eaat2382.

  • Perry M, Waite H, Perryman R, et al. The flow of material inward from Saturn's rings. InEGU Gen. Assem. Conf. Abstr. 2018:16834.

  • Rostrup-Nielsen J, Christiansen LJ. Concepts in syngas manufacture. World Scientific; 2011.

  • Heidenreich S, Foscolo PU. New concepts in biomass gasification. Prog. energy combust. sci., 2015;46:72-95.

  • Canup RM. Origin of Saturn’s rings and inner moons by mass removal from a lost Titan-sized satellite. Nature. 2010 Dec;468(7326):943-6.

  • Diamagnetic materials

  • Reis Guilherme. Thermal influence on the diamagnetic properties of pyrolytic graphite: Applications in space and high speed transportation. 2016.

  • Wahlund JE, Morooka MW, Hadid L, et al. First In-Situ Determination of the Ionospheric Structure of Saturn by Cassini/RPWS. Saturn. 2017.

  • Tchernyi VV, Kapranov SV, Pospelov AY. Role of Electromagnetism in the Origin of Saturn’s Rings Due to Diamagnetism of Their Ice Particles: JC Maxwell Had Almost Solved the Rings Origin Problem. URSI Radio Sci. Lett. 2021;3:69.

  • Tchernyi VV, Kapranov SV, Pospelov AY. Contribution of magnetism to the origin and stability of the rings of Saturn due to superconductivity of protoplanetary iced particles. arXiv preprint arXiv:2004.13212. 2020.

  • D’Aversa E, Bellucci G, Filacchione G, et al. Ir spectra of saturn’s ring spokes and multiple shines in the saturn-rings system. In EGU Gen. Assem. Conf. Abstr,2017: 9140

  • E D’Aversa, G Bellucci, F Altieri, et al. Spectral characteristics of a spoke on the Saturn rings. Memorie della Societa Astronomica Italiana Supplementi, 2011;16:70.

  • Kobayashi M, Abe J. Optical motion control of maglev graphite. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2012;134(51):20593-6.

  • Aslam F, Farooq F, Amin MN, et al. Applications of gene expression programming for estimating compressive strength of high-strength concrete. Adv. Civ. Eng.;2020:1-23.

  • Farooq F, Akbar A, Khushnood RA. Effect of hybrid carbon nanotubes/graphite nano platelets on mechanical properties of cementitious composite. InProceedings 1st Conf. Sustain. Civ. Eng.2019

  • Electrical Conductivity in Graphite

  • The Mysterious Spokes

  • Horányi M, Hartquist TW, Havnes O, et al. Dusty plasma effects in Saturn's magnetosphere. Rev. Geophys.2004;42(4).

  • D'Aversa E, Bellucci G, Nicholson PD, et al. The spectrum of a Saturn ring spoke from Cassini/VIMS. Geophys. res. lett. 2010;37(1).

  • Ciarniello M, Filacchione G, D’Aversa E, et al. Cassini-vims observations of saturn’s main rings: Ii. a spectrophotometric study by means of monte carlo ray-tracing and hapke’s theory. Icarus, 2019;317:242–65.

  • Cuzzi JN, Estrada PR. Compositional evolution of Saturn's rings due to meteoroid bombardment. Icarus. 1998;132(1):1-35.

  • Poulet F, Cuzzi JN. The composition of Saturn's rings. Icarus. 2002;160(2):350-8.

  • Poulet F, Cruikshank DP, Cuzzi JN, et al. Compositions of Saturn's rings A, B, and C from high resolution near-infrared spectroscopic observations.Astron. Astrophys. 2003;412(1):305-16.

  • Cruikshank DP, Imanaka H, Dalle Ore CM. Tholins as coloring agents on outer Solar System bodies. Adv. Space Res. 2005;36(2):178-83.


Abstract Views: 101

PDF Views: 0




  • An Alternative Explanation of the ‘Spokes’ Observed in Saturn’s Rings

Abstract Views: 101  |  PDF Views: 0

Authors

Fenton J. Doolan
Independent Researcher, Secondary Teacher + HoD Science, Australia., Australia

Abstract


Observed first by amateur astronomer Stephen J. O’Meara in the 1970s and then subsequently observed by the Voyager Spacecraft flybys in the early 1980s (FIG. 1)[1], it was realized that the ‘spokes’ flare out like spokes on a bicycle wheel. The observed behavior of the ‘spokes’ indicates that they are not governed by gravitational interactions with the planet, moons, or ring material. In 2005 the Cassini probe confirmed that the ‘spokes’ are likely under the influence of the gas giant’s global magnetic field[2]. Here we show the ‘spokes’ that appear in Saturn’s rings consist of grains of silicates coated in pyrolytic carbon through the process of Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD).

Pyrolytic carbon is a highly diamagnetic substance that can levitate above a sufficiently strong magnetic field. The ‘spokes’ also consist of ice particles that are diamagnetic as well. The photoelectric effect can be used to explain why the silicates coated in pyrolytic carbon return to the main ring structure when exposed to sunlight of a specific frequency. The pyrolytic carbon grains become paramagnetic when some of the unhybridised 2pz orbitals lose their unpaired delocalized electrons, thus collapsing the π bond molecular orbital structure. The pyrolytic carbon grains are now attracted towards the magnetic field emanating above and below the main ring structure. It is suggested that the ‘spokes’ in Saturn’s B ring are always present and that no plasma triggering event is required to increase plasma density. The ‘spokes’, however, are only visible when a favorable viewing angle is allowed, and their visibility is also dependent on the angle of the sunlight hitting Saturn’s rings.


Keywords


Diamagnetic, Photoelectric Effect

References