Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription Access

An Investigative Analysis About the Understanding and Determinants, if Any, of the Self Economic Dependency Ratio (SEDR) in the Select Gram Panchayats of West Bengal:A Case Study in the District of Bankura


Affiliations
1 Department of Economics, BankuraZillaSaradamoniMahilaMahavidyapith, Bankura-722101, West Bengal, India
 

Objectives: (1) Compare and contrast the status of Self Economic Dependency Ratio (SEDR) in between two ideologically different political set up of fifteen select GPs in the district of Bankura in West Bengal. (2) Panel data regression analysis was carried out to unravel and explain, if possible, the variations of Self Economic Dependency Ratio ( SEDR) by the select Politico- Socio-Economic factors of the select village Panchayats, (2) and also to understand the relationship , if any, between the Grants-in-aid and the Self Economic Dependency Ratio (SEDR) of the Village Panchayats under study for verifying the existing literatures about the relationship between Grants-in-aid and Own Source Revenue (OSR) / economic development albeit with an alternative indicator namely, Self-Economic Dependency Ratio(SEDR) and finally (4) prescribing ways and means especially to the Government of West Bengal for bringing about more participatory and inclusive in nature traits into the system of Panchayat financing.

Methodology: In addition of conventional Desk research, field survey, Interview and Focus Group Discussions use of Panel data regression analysis with suitably chosen models using both STATA and SPSS software were meticulously used to arrive at important observations at the end.

Findings: In majority sample Panchayats (53.33%) growth rates in Total expenditure during the TMC ruled government became negative which was one of the important reasons for higher self-economic dependency ratio during the TMC ruled government in comparison to the Left front led government. On the issue of self-economic dependency ratio as an important indicator for strengthening own source revenue generation capacity to meet their own basic needs or as a signal of improvement in gram Panchayat finance has been witnessing marginal improvement over time and the change in political set up could only alter the situation marginally.Our panel data regression analysis found that SEDRs were negatively influenced by the percentage of Below Poverty Line Households and positively by the Political regimes. Thus a sign of improvement in terms of own source revenue generation capacity of the select village Panchayats was at least ushered in during the TMC ruled government. The relation between SEDR and Grants-in-aid was found to be negative and significant. Thus result (significant negative relation between SEDR and Grants-in-aid) did not support the earlier findings in the literature of Panchayat financing.

Application/Improvement: Using Panel data regression analysis to explain the variations of Self Economic Dependency Ratio (SEDR) by the select Politico- Socio-Economic Indicators, if any, of the select village Panchayats was undoubtedly a significant departure from the earlier studies. Elaborative study on the nature and pattern of own resource mobilization, Total expenditure and finally via an alternative and more effective indicator namely, Self-Economic Dependency Ratio (SEDR) under ideologically different political dispensations was also another distinctive feature of the study.


Keywords

Raj Institutions, Self-Economic Dependency Ratio, Panel Data, Politico-Socio-Economic Factors.
User
Notifications

  • N. Patra, A. K. Chattopadhyay. Patterns of growth and usage of Panchayat finance: a case study of Bankura in West Bengal. International Journal of Social Science & Economic Research. 2018; 3(5), 1-28.
  • A. Sharma, D. Chakravarty. Integrating the third tier in the Indian federal system: two decades of rural local governance. Singapore: Palgrave Macmillan. 2018.
  • M.A. Oommen, S. Wallace, A. Muwonge. Towards streamlining Panchayat finance in India.EPW. 2017; 52(38).
  • Revenue Mobilization by Gram Panchayats of West Bengal: Present Situation and Policy Options. http://www.issin.org/Revenue-Mobilization-by-Gram-Panchayats-of-West-Bengal.pdf. Date accessed: 06/2015.
  • Study on Understanding Determinants of Own Source Revenue in Gram Panchayats of Karnataka, http://rdpr.kar.nic.in/document/Understanding%20Determinants%20of%20GPs'%20OSR%20%20Final%20Report%20120413.pdf. Date accessed: 01/2013.
  • M.A. Oommen. The third tier and the fourteenth finance commission. Economic and Political Weekly. 2013; 48 (45-46).
  • A.Sahasranama. Panchayat finances and the need for devolutions from the State Government. Economic and Political Weekly. 2012, Vol. 47(4).
  • R.M. Bird. Subnational taxation in developing countries: a review of the literature. JICEP, World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. 2011; 2(01), 139-161.
  • Subnational Taxation in Developing Countries: A Review of the Literature. https://ideas.repec.org/a/wsi/jicepx/v02y2011i01ns1793993311000269.html. Date accessed: 2011.
  • Bahl, Roy, G. Sethi, S. Wallace. West Bengal: fiscal decentralization to rural governments - analysis and reform options. Georgia State University, Atlanta. 2009.
  • N.Patra , A.K. Chattopadhyay. Growth and sectoral analysis of Panchayat finance in West Bengal during 1990-91 to 2013-14. Indian Journal of Economics and Development. 2018; 6(5).
  • M.A. Oommen. Limits of a devolution index. Economic and Political Weekly. 2009; 44(29).
  • M. Gupta, P.R Jena. Revenue efforts of Panchayats: evidence from four states. Economic and Political Weekly. 2008; 43(30).

Abstract Views: 251

PDF Views: 138




  • An Investigative Analysis About the Understanding and Determinants, if Any, of the Self Economic Dependency Ratio (SEDR) in the Select Gram Panchayats of West Bengal:A Case Study in the District of Bankura

Abstract Views: 251  |  PDF Views: 138

Authors

Nityananda Patra
Department of Economics, BankuraZillaSaradamoniMahilaMahavidyapith, Bankura-722101, West Bengal, India

Abstract


Objectives: (1) Compare and contrast the status of Self Economic Dependency Ratio (SEDR) in between two ideologically different political set up of fifteen select GPs in the district of Bankura in West Bengal. (2) Panel data regression analysis was carried out to unravel and explain, if possible, the variations of Self Economic Dependency Ratio ( SEDR) by the select Politico- Socio-Economic factors of the select village Panchayats, (2) and also to understand the relationship , if any, between the Grants-in-aid and the Self Economic Dependency Ratio (SEDR) of the Village Panchayats under study for verifying the existing literatures about the relationship between Grants-in-aid and Own Source Revenue (OSR) / economic development albeit with an alternative indicator namely, Self-Economic Dependency Ratio(SEDR) and finally (4) prescribing ways and means especially to the Government of West Bengal for bringing about more participatory and inclusive in nature traits into the system of Panchayat financing.

Methodology: In addition of conventional Desk research, field survey, Interview and Focus Group Discussions use of Panel data regression analysis with suitably chosen models using both STATA and SPSS software were meticulously used to arrive at important observations at the end.

Findings: In majority sample Panchayats (53.33%) growth rates in Total expenditure during the TMC ruled government became negative which was one of the important reasons for higher self-economic dependency ratio during the TMC ruled government in comparison to the Left front led government. On the issue of self-economic dependency ratio as an important indicator for strengthening own source revenue generation capacity to meet their own basic needs or as a signal of improvement in gram Panchayat finance has been witnessing marginal improvement over time and the change in political set up could only alter the situation marginally.Our panel data regression analysis found that SEDRs were negatively influenced by the percentage of Below Poverty Line Households and positively by the Political regimes. Thus a sign of improvement in terms of own source revenue generation capacity of the select village Panchayats was at least ushered in during the TMC ruled government. The relation between SEDR and Grants-in-aid was found to be negative and significant. Thus result (significant negative relation between SEDR and Grants-in-aid) did not support the earlier findings in the literature of Panchayat financing.

Application/Improvement: Using Panel data regression analysis to explain the variations of Self Economic Dependency Ratio (SEDR) by the select Politico- Socio-Economic Indicators, if any, of the select village Panchayats was undoubtedly a significant departure from the earlier studies. Elaborative study on the nature and pattern of own resource mobilization, Total expenditure and finally via an alternative and more effective indicator namely, Self-Economic Dependency Ratio (SEDR) under ideologically different political dispensations was also another distinctive feature of the study.


Keywords


Raj Institutions, Self-Economic Dependency Ratio, Panel Data, Politico-Socio-Economic Factors.

References